Ice Cream Flavors


Award winning super-premium gourmet ice cream shipped specially for Gaetano’s from the Wisconsin Dairyland. We feature 16 of the more than 110 Chocolate Shoppe flavors and rotate them frequently so you can taste them all. We are serving up your favorites in your choice of single or double dip cups or cones, shakes, malts and sundaes.

Flavors changed daily

  • Junior Cup $2.15
  • Single Cup (Wafer or Sugar) $2.70
  • Single Dip (Waffle) $3.50
  • Double Dip (Wafer or Sugar) $3.80
  • Double Dip (Waffle) $4.60
  • Pint of Ice Cream $4.95
  • Quart of Ice Cream $8.60


Banana Cream Pie Your favorite comfort food now on a cone! Banana ice cream churned with a marshmallow ripple and real Nilla Wafers.
Birthday Cake Sweet birthday cake-flavored ice cream with swirls of blue frosting and heaps of colorful confetti sprinkles.
Blue Moon  Just like the milk in the bottom of a Fruit Loops bowl, this tasty ice cream has a sweet Fruit Loops taste and a wacky blue color.
Blueberry Cheesecake Delectable cheesecake ice cream topped off with a tangy blueberry ripple and lush cheesecake pieces.
Bourbon Pecan Pie Smooth bourbon ice cream swirled with a sea salt chocolate fudge ripple and roasted pecans.
Brownie Cascade Classic, creamy chocolate ice cream exploding with brownie pieces, caramel cups and a sweet fudge ripple.
Butter Pecan Buttery pecan ice cream with boat-loads of crispy, lightly roasted and salted pecans.
Cake Batter Fudge With a scrumptious cake batter-base, thick chocolate frosting swirls and lush brownie pieces, this ice cream settles all arguments over the mixing spoon!
Cappuccino Break Crisp coffee-infused ice cream with gobs of chocolate covered toffee and candy coated almonds.
Caramel Apple Pie Spicy cinnamon ice cream mixed with chunks of real apples, crispy cinnamon shortbread pieces and a thick caramel ripple.
Caramel Chaos Luscious caramel ice cream packed with mini caramel cups and gobs of marble cream caramel.
Caramel Choco-Latte Espresso ice cream with thick caramel and fudge ripples, chocolate covered caramel cups and soft chocolate chunks.
Choc Raspberry Truffle  Rich, chocolate ice cream loaded with chunks of soft brownies, delicious covered raspberry cups and a sweet raspberry ripple.  
Coconut Almond Bliss Tropical coconut-flavored ice cream with tons of melt-in-your-mouth liquid chocolate chips and crispy almond pieces.
Cotton Candy Twist Blue and pink cotton candy-flavored ice creams swirled together for that whimsical carnival sensation!
Cookie Dough Sweet cookie-flavored ice cream with heaps of soft chocolate chip cookie dough chunks and tons of rich, liquid chocolate chips.
Dark Side of the Moon Dark Zanzibar Chocolate swirled with sweet Blue Moon for a flavor that’s out of this world!
Door County Cherry Sweet, all natural vanilla ice cream bursting with real Door County Cherries from Sister Bay, Wisconsin.
Egg Nog A holiday favorite!  Heavenly ice cream overflowing with that smooth, traditional egg nog taste.  
Espresso Almond Fudge Crisp coffee-infused ice cream with a smooth chocolate fudge ripple and tons of crunchy almond pieces.
Espresso Oreo Crisp coffee-infused ice cream loaded with heaps of sweet Oreos
Exhausted Parent Bourbon-spiked espresso ice cream swirled with bittersweet chocolate chunks
Fat Elvis Sweet banana ice cream all shook up with a salty peanut butter ripple and rich liquid chocolate chips.
French Silk A heavenly combination of chocolate mousse ice cream and flakes of decadent, dark chocolate
Green Tea  A Zen-inspiring treat made with sweet ice cream and infused with calming, natural green tea.
Halley’s Comet A perfect trio of flavors with rich chocolate and vanilla ice creams swirled together with a caramel ribbon and loads of sweet chocolate-covered caramel cups. 
Heaps Of Love Anything and everything you can want! Oreos, brownies, cookie dough, caramel ripple, pecans and chocolate ripple all packed into vanilla ice cream.
Key Lime Pie Can you say pucker up? You will after this southern pie flavor made of tart lime ice cream, sour lime candies and graham cracker pieces.
Kitty Kitty Bang Bang Irresistibly smooth cheesecake ice cream crafted with a sweet raspberry ripple, Oreo pieces and soft chocolate chunks.
Lemon Meringue Fresh lemon and fluffy marshmallow ice creams swirl together with a tart lemon ripple for the perfect, refreshing treat on a hot, summer day.
Malt Amore Old-style malted milk ice cream packed with rich, malt flavor, super-premium chocolate chips and ripples of sweet, chocolate fudge.
Mint Avalanche A mint lover’s paradise! Fresh green mint ice cream loaded with Andes Candies and Grasshopper cookies, and topped off with a sweet chocolate fudge swirl.
Mint Chip Our perfected rendition of the classic. Fresh mint ice cream loaded with melt-in-your-mouth liquid chocolate chips.
Mint Oreo Crispy green mint ice cream with boat-loads of sweet Oreos.
Moose Tracks Delicious vanilla ice cream packed with mini chocolate peanut butter cups and swirls of dreamy chocolate fudge.
Munchie Madness Sweet cake batter ice cream swirled with a salted caramel ripple and brimming with Oreos, M&M pieces and peanut butter cups.
Old-Fashioned Vanilla Our award-winning and all-natural take on classic vanilla ice cream, bursting with flavor from our own special blend of rich, pure vanilla extracts.
Peanut Butter Cup Smooth chocolate ice cream brimming with mouthwatering peanut butter ripples and rich peanut butter cups
Peanut Butter Cookie Dough Luscious vanilla ice cream loaded with gobs of soft cookie dough chunks, creamy chocolate chips and a thick peanut butter ripple.
Peppermint Stick Bursting with candy cane flavor in every bite, this creamy pepermint ice cream is made with boat-loads of crisp, peppermint candies.
Pistachio Nut Irresistible almond-flavored ice cream overflowing with tons of crisp pistachio nuts.
Rainbow Sherbet Orange, Lime, and Raspberry flavored sherbets classically swirled together.
Rocky Road Chocolate ice cream flavored with African cocoa butter, swirled with fluffy marshmallow ice cream and loaded with tons of chocolate covered almonds.
Scotch Ale Caramel Crunch Stone of Scone Scotch Ale ice cream with a sweet caramel ripple and crunchy heath candy pieces.
Snap-O-Lantern An award-winning combination of spicy pumpkin-flavored ice cream and heaps of gingersnap cookies to partner the cooling autumn weather.
Snickers & Fudge  Lush vanilla ice cream enhanced with boat-loads of crushed Snickers and a divine chocolate fudge ripple. 
Sticks and Stones Soft cookie dough chunks, crisp chocolate covered pretzels and  a gooey salted caramel ripple all swirled into our rich chocolate ice cream.
Strawberry Award-winning and deliciously fresh strawberry ice cream loaded to the brim with real, whole strawberries.
Strawberry Cheesecake Delightful cheesecake ice cream with a strawberry ripple and loads of gooey cheesecake pieces.
Superman  A fruity-flavored ice cream with soaring swirls of Superman red, yellow and blue.
This $&@! Just Got Serious Smooth salted caramel ice cream brimming with rich sea salt fudge and salted cashews.
Turtle Luscious vanilla ice cream with rich swirls of thick chocolate fudge, sweet caramel fudge, and bunches of lightly roasted and salted pecans.

Ultimate Oreo  Scrumptious Oreo crumb-based ice cream with boat-loads of real Oreos.
Yippee Skippee Creamy peanut butter ice cream loaded with salted caramel ripples, chunks of soft brownies and crispy chocolate-covered pretzels.
Zanzibar  All-natural chocolate ice cream made with three kinds of cocoa for a rich, fudge brownie taste!
Zanziberry Shortcake Our award-winning Zanzibar and Strawberry ice creams swirled together with a marshmalow ripple and shortcake pieces
Zoreo Fudge-like Zanzibar chocolate ice cream with a gooey marshmallow ripple, sweet Oreos and soft chocolate chunks.
Zanzimint Fudge-like Zanzibar chocolate ice cream swirled with fresh green mint ice cream.